Hedge
Funds vs Private Equity Firms in the Alternative
Investment Community
Jayesh
Punater, CEO and Founder
Gravitas Technology
November 2005
Hedge funds have led the charge in the
alternative investment community as a viable
and growing segment of the buy side/asset
gathering industry. Some of the brightest
and smartest people from the industry have
not only started hedge funds, but lately
have started large "institutional",
multi-strategy funds that span the globe
looking for opportunities in which to trade.
However, lately, as a technology provider
to this industry, we at Gravitas are noticing
with increasing frequency, private equity
firms "spinning out" of larger
institutions and establishing their own
identities. Furthermore, many "hybrids"
have followed in their own rite. Under the
structure of a fund, the "hybrids"
trade multi-strategies which combine traditional
hedge fund investments and private equity
investments. Many traditional hedge funds
are finding it difficult to produce attractive
alpha (delta between the performance of
the index and their fund returns), and therefore
are looking for other instruments/vehicles
in which to trade. Hence they are selectively
exploring both the private equity and real
estate sectors.
What is the Difference?
Most hedge funds have portfolio managers
that will actively allocate the funds amongst
different securities, primarily in public
companies or securities that are traded
through some liquid or over the counter
marketplace. Hence they rely on real-time
market data, to market their holdings on
a daily or even on an intra-day basis, and
have to first gather the assets which are
"domiciled" with the custodian
or the prime broker. The typical hedge fund
will charge 1-2% management fee and anywhere
from 20% or more incentive or profit-sharing
fee. Many hedge funds, especially the larger
and more successful ones, may ask their
clients to "lock up" assets for
up to a period of three years. However,
the gains and losses in the funds are reported
monthly and tracked daily by the funds'
management.
Private equity firms may charge fees on
a similar basis, ie a management fee and
a performance fee. Generally these firms
will have commitments on assets from their
investors on which they can call, as and
when they are required. An investor typically
does not have to transfer funds into the
private equity firm until the funds are
"called" based upon the investments
the firm is making. These firms invest in
private firms (hence private equity), or
take a private stake in public firms (PIPES),
and do not mark to market their holdings
as there may not be a public valuation of
them until an exit or sale is occurred.
It is then that they realise their profits.
These firms have much longer life-cycles
(typically) in the investments they make
as opposed to hedge funds, and do not require
real-time market data-feeds. The lock-up
for private equity firms is frequently seven
years or more. These firms are trading illiquid
assets and need a much longer period to
identify, invest and then exit the companies.
Generally, the managers participate in the
upscale profits on a cumulative basis whereas
profits are offset by any losses.
Another difference is in risk management.
While hedge funds use metrics like VaR and
look at alpha and beta (market and absolute
correlation), the private equity firms have
a more bottom-up approach to risk management
based upon research and the management team
of the companies in which they take a stake.
The types of investors these institutions
attract also vary. While hedge funds predominantly
have had traditionally high net worth investors,
and recently more and more institutional
investors, they also have been more accessible
to individual investors. Private equity
firms, on the other hand, are generally
less accessible to individual high net worth
investors and attract more ultra-high net
worth investors and institutional investors.
This may be a function of the typically
longer lock-up periods in the private equity
firms, and the less liquid nature of their
investments.
Examples of some of the larger hedge funds
are ESL, Eton Park, Farallon Capital, Moore
Capital, Och-Ziff, and TPG-Axon while examples
of private equity firms are The BlackStone
Group, The Carlyle Group, JP Morgan Capital
Partners, TowerBrook Capital and the Texas
Pacific Group.
Besides their business models, these firms
also differ in their needs and consumption
of technology. Hedge funds tend to require
a much more robust and fault intolerant
technology implementation as they have various
applications like an order management system,
portfolio accounting system, risk management
system and various market data vendor feeds
like Bloomberg, Reuters and so on. Private
equity firms primarily need a good and reliable
phone system, email and ability to share
MS Word, Excel and PowerPoint files. Hence
they need much simpler network infrastructures.
Both, however, have a demanding end-user
community that demands top-notch service
and timely response to their respective
requirements. Hedge funds typically use
one or multiple prime brokers and fund administrators,
whereas private equity firms typically do
not require any.
To summarise, while hedge funds lead the
charge in being the first to create an alternative
to traditional investment vehicles for (high
net worth) individuals and institutions,
private equity shops are also beginning
to proliferate and grow, and spin out of
larger institutions. Both types of businesses
are similar in many ways, but also have
certain distinct characteristics with regards
to the investors they attract, the kind
of operations they need to set up and the
technology they need to support them, both
internal and that provided by third parties.
About Gravitas
Gravitas Technology,
with its "white glove" services
approach and multiple legs of offering where
we view technology holistically, has been
providing a broad range of integrated IT
services including consulting, software
development and infrastructure integration
since 1996. Our customers include an impressive
portfolio of financial services firms, including
hedge funds, brokerage firms, investment
banks and asset management firms.
We have expanded our
delivery capacity and enriched our offerings
with best-of-breed delivery partners including:
Constatin/Walsh-Lowe, Globix Corporation,
and MTM Technologies. Gravitas continues
to be the preferred provider of IT services
to the hedge fund industry, having secured
the launches of over 25 funds, including
some of the largest and most complicated
hedge fund clients over the last 12 months.